Action on Sugar’s Professor Graham MacGregor Misses the Point

Almost missed this letter to the editor of Food from Action On Sugar’s Chairman Professor Graham MacGregor, in which he makes a rather remarkable statement

We are not claiming that their is anything uniquely damaging about sugar, apart from the fact that added sugar is a completely unnecessary source of calories and a cause of dental caries.

I find this extraordinary for a number of reasons, firstly, you might argue that forming a single issue lobby group Action on Sugar

…a group of specialists concerned with sugar and its effects on health.

itself strongly implies that sugar has unique effects on health which need to be tackled.

Secondly you might point out that the idea that added sugar is uniquely dangerous beyond its effects on obesity has been the central theme in Action on Sugar’s 3 month long media campaign. At various times, Action on sugar have made the following claims about the dangers of sugar consumption:-

This is not singling out sugar as uniquely damaging? I’m sure Professor MacGregor would argue that these are clearly stated as ‘links’ and ‘associations’ rather than causative but when you continually bombard the public with claims about the harms from sugar – often whilst simultaneously espousing the virtues of once demonised fat – the cumulative effect is to establish that very premise.

I don’t know if Professor MacGregor cannot recognise this, or if he is profoundly ignorant of the activities of a campaign which he chairs. Certainly when Action on Sugar’s own launch day press release states the following

Common sense’ and the food industry say that all calories are the same. But the science says that sugar is different – that sugar is dangerous exclusive of its calories, just like alcohol.

it leaves him looking rather foolish.


One thought on “Action on Sugar’s Professor Graham MacGregor Misses the Point

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s